Raman had promised his family Goa.
For a lower middle-class clerk from Nagpur, a promise like that was not made lightly. It was born on a sweaty summer night, whispered to his wife Meena as their children slept on the floor mattress—twelve-year-old Rishi sprawled like a starfish, and eight-year-old Ananya clutching her doll. Raman had no savings worth the name, but he had resolve, and a habit of honouring his word.
They travelled by overnight bus, knees jammed, tempers frayed, the children oscillating between excitement and nausea. By dawn, Goa greeted them with palm trees, salt-laden air, and the roar of the Arabian Sea. Raman found a cheap lodge—peeling paint, a reluctant ceiling fan, but clean sheets and a balcony from where one could hear waves arguing with the shore.
The first morning, they went to the beach early, before the tourists woke and before the sun turned cruel. The sand was cool, damp, and dotted with fishermen hauling nets that shimmered like silver lace. Raman waded into the water to rinse his feet when he noticed a middle-aged man struggling waist-deep in the surf.
The man was stout, moustached, and clearly unused to the sea. His wife stood anxiously at a distance, shouting instructions that the waves ignored.
Raman hurried over, held the man steady, and guided him through the ritual of dipping, splashing, and retreating before the next wave struck. The man emerged breathless but triumphant.
“Ram Ram sa,” he said, folding his hands. “I am Banwari Lal, from Rajasthan. The sea is more aggressive than our desert winds.”
Raman smiled. “The sea has moods, sahib. You just met a bad one.”
Banwari Lal laughed, a deep, prosperous laugh, the kind that came from full stomachs and successful deals. He introduced his wife and called out to his servant, Viru—a lean, sharp-eyed man in his thirties, who soon struck up an easy conversation with Raman over coconut water.
Viru had the rare talent of making friends without trying. He admired Raman for bringing his family by bus; Raman admired Viru for his fearless dive into the waves. By the end of the morning, they were exchanging hotel names and dinner plans.
That evening, Banwari Lal mentioned something curious. During a stroll through the Mapusa flea market, he had bought an old brass lamp from a toothless antique seller.
“Pure junk,” his wife sniffed.
“Or pure luck,” Banwari Lal said cryptically.
The lamp was unmistakable—long-spouted, round-bellied, etched with fading Arabic patterns, darkened by age and neglect. It looked like it had escaped straight from an illustration of Aladdin.
The next morning, Viru came running to Raman’s lodge, breathless and pale.
“Babuji is missing,” he said. “Since dawn. His phone is off. His room untouched.”
He clutched the brass lamp like a child holding a relic.
Raman frowned. “Where did you get this?”
“Last night,” Viru said. “Babuji was polishing it, rubbing it again and again, joking about wishes. He told me to keep it safe. Now he is gone.”
They went straight to the police station, where Detective Miranda listened in silence.
Miranda was portly, calm, and permanently accompanied by a pipe that never seemed fully lit yet always smelled faintly of tobacco. He had the heavy-lidded eyes and patient stillness of a man who believed crimes confessed themselves if given enough time. If Georges Simenon’s Maigret had been reborn in Goa, he would have looked exactly like Miranda—minus the French accent, replaced instead by a soft Konkani lilt.
Beside him sat Sophia, his assistant—sharp, efficient, notebook always open, pen moving even when no one seemed to be speaking. She recorded coughs, pauses, and raised eyebrows with equal seriousness.
“A missing businessman,” Miranda said slowly. “A lamp. And a beach. Goa never disappoints.”
Two days passed. Banwari Lal did not surface.
Miranda visited Banwari Lal’s hotel, examined the room, and asked for the lamp. Something about it bothered him—the excessive polishing marks, the reverence with which Viru handled it.
“This lamp,” Miranda said, tapping it gently with his pipe, “has seen more than it admits.”
He took it to his office and asked Constable Ghorpade to guard it.
The next morning, Miranda nearly dropped his pipe.
A Marwari gentleman sat calmly across his desk, sipping tea.
“I am Banwari Lal,” the man said.
Sophia entered just then. “Sir, Constable Ghorpade is missing. Night duty. Lamp intact.”
Miranda stared at the lamp. Then at Banwari Lal. Then at the empty chair where Ghorpade should have been guarding the lamp.
The dots aligned.
Miranda leaned forward. “Tell me,” he said gently, “how many wishes did you ask for?”
Banwari Lal’s shoulders sagged.
He spoke of greed disguised as curiosity. Of wishes for wealth, then power, then immortality. Of how the lamp had warned him—twice only. The third wish had reversed the bargain. The genie had walked free, and Banwari Lal had been trapped inside the brass prison.
“Ghorpade rubbed it,” he whispered. “He wished.”
Miranda nodded. “And became what you were.”
He leaned back, exhaled a slow ribbon of smoke, and looked at Sophia.
“Now tell me,” he said, “how does one rescue a constable who is currently a supernatural civil servant trapped inside antique brass?”
Sophia did not look up from her notebook. “Sir, as per procedure, we cannot issue a missing person notice for someone who is technically not a person at the moment.”
Miranda sighed. “Goa Police manuals are very limited in imagination.”
She finally looked up. “However, we do have assets.”
Miranda raised an eyebrow. “If you say budget, I will retire today.”
“Salim,” Sophia said calmly.
Miranda stopped mid-puff. “The serial killer Salim?”
“Yes, sir. The one who enjoys bargaining, believes he is smarter than destiny, and has already filed six mercy petitions.”
Miranda smiled faintly. “And costs the exchequer how much per year?”
Sophia flipped a page. “Enough to fund three police jeeps, one monsoon bridge repair, and your pipe tobacco for life.”
Miranda nodded approvingly. “Excellent. Tempt him.”
“With the lamp?”
“With greed,” Miranda corrected. “The lamp is only the delivery system.”
Sophia allowed herself a rare smile. “We tell Salim that rubbing the lamp grants wishes. We supervise. Two wishes allowed.”
“And the third?” Miranda asked.
“He will insist,” Sophia said. “They always do.”
Miranda chuckled. “Criminal psychology is wonderfully predictable.”
The plan worked with embarrassing ease.
Salim rubbed the lamp, wished for power, then freedom. The third wish escaped before Miranda could even light his pipe.
By evening, Constable Ghorpade was back—confused, hungry, and requesting leave.
The lamp sat quietly on the table.
Sophia closed her notebook. “Case resolved. One constable recovered. One trial saved. Budget balanced.”
Miranda tapped the lamp gently. “Justice,” he said, “sometimes needs imagination.”
Banwari Lal left the lamp behind.
Later that evening, Raman received a parcel at his lodge—an envelope thick with cash and a note:
For keeping promises, even to your family. —B.L.
Raman looked at the sea that night, held Meena’s hand, and felt content.
Some promises, he realised, were better than wishes.
